Why 20% Growth in Fundraising Is Achievable

If you’ve been in nonprofit fundraising circles long enough, you’ve likely heard this argument:

“Expecting 20% year-over-year growth is unrealistic.”

At PhoenixFire Strategic Consulting, we disagree. Not only is 20% annual growth possible, we’ve helped clients achieve it sustainably, and in many cases, far exceed it.

That’s not bravado. It's a strategic reality.

When a nonprofit is positioned correctly with the right processes, messaging, and mindset, 20% growth is a well-structured plan.

---

When 20% Is the Floor, Not the Ceiling

Too often, fundraisers are told to calibrate their expectations to sector-wide benchmarks. While projections from Giving USA and other authorities show that individual giving increases by 3%–4% nationally, those averages include stagnant programs, underfunded departments, and legacy organizations content with maintaining the status quo.

We’ve worked with organizations that have seen 600% growth in under two years. Others have tripled donor bases, doubled average gift sizes, or built entirely new revenue streams, all without sacrificing donor relationships or sustainability.

Is that typical? No.

Is it replicable? Yes, with the right conditions.

---

Three Levers for Strategic Growth

To sustainably achieve 20% or more annual growth, you need to pull three very real, very actionable levers:

1. Donor Acquisition

Targeted outreach, refined messaging, and better segmentation bring new supporters into your ecosystem. We use advanced AI-powered prospecting, social listening, and digital strategies to identify and attract the right donors for your cause.

2. Donation Velocity

This is about how quickly and how often people give. The right tools can enhance donation management, automate follow-ups and acknowledgments, and significantly reduce the time between donor engagement and giving.

3. Donor Gift Size

By segmenting communications, personalizing asks, and telling better stories, we help clients increase the average gift without alienating entry-level donors. We use real-time data to identify upgrade-ready donors and implement thoughtful communication so they feel like partners, not ATMs.

These levers don’t operate in isolation. When activated together, they compound growth in powerful ways.

---

The PhoenixFire Advantage: Strategy Meets Innovation

We don’t rely on “hope” or “more hours” to drive results.

PhoenixFire Strategic Consulting is years ahead of the curve when it comes to deploying innovative tools that scale capacity, improve donor experience, and increase internal efficiency. That includes, but goes far beyond, simply “using ChatGPT.”

We integrate AI into prospect research, automated engagement funnels, grant writing support, social media content creation, data analysis, and performance prediction modeling. Recently, McKinsey reported that data-driven companies outperform competitors by up to 20%. The number is even higher when AI tools are integrated with that data. 

Our tech stack is purpose-built to multiply human effort, not replace it, and it’s all tailored for nonprofits with real-world context. It’s about using AI strategically, to  get more done with less stress.

---

So, Can You Hit 20% Growth?

If you’re:

• Starting from a entry-level or stagnant baseline,

• Under-leveraged in digital outreach,

• Sitting on unstructured donor data,

• Operating with a small but committed team,

  
  

…then yes. You can.

We’re not saying it’s going to be easy. We’re saying it’s doable, especially if you’re ready to stop following the average and start building what’s possible.

---

Let’s talk about your 20%. Or your 200%.

Visit www.phoenixfiresc.com to learn how we can help you unlock your next chapter of growth.